Advancing Innovation and Impact with CGIAR

The objective of the causal impact assessment is to conduct a comprehensive scoping phase to identify potential innovations that may have scaled in countries where CGIAR operates. This assessment focuses on five key impact areas and aims to engage in a more systematic scoping of potential learning and accountability studies. This involves providing technical assistance and follow-up beyond initial discussions. Systematic evidence of the reach of CGIAR innovations and policy influences needs to be combined with rigorous causal estimates of their impact in the five targeted impact areas of the CGIAR Research and Innovation strategy. 

Rigorous causal estimates are particularly relevant for identifying "big-win" innovations and policies with large reach and for interventions addressing last-mile delivery problems that may limit impacts at scale. To facilitate the implementation of the most relevant independent causal impact studies, SPIA will systematically scope potential causal "learning" and "accountability" studies through hands-on technical assistance and follow-up with CGIAR researchers, and by linking them with internal and external impact assessment experts.

  • Accountability Studies: Accountability studies document long-term, large-scale impacts of CGIAR research on development outcomes.
  • Learning-oriented studies: Learning studies focus on innovations that have not yet experienced widespread uptake and impact. These could be recent innovations or older ones that have not gone to scale despite solid evidence that they could provide substantial (net) benefits to users. Learning studies are designed to inform future research processes and scaling strategies and are closely linked to the ToC of the specific research programs. The results of learning studies can help make stage-gating decisions.
  • Methodological studies: In addition to accountability and learning studies, SPIA also supports work on methods development in areas where lack of appropriate methods make it hard to measure impacts of important areas of CGIAR research.

 

On-Going Studies

 

Table 1. On-Going Studies
StudyCategoryPartnersCountry
Group-based ICT Extension Support Systems: Evidence from Rural Peru (Go Digital PERU)LearningCIP, Michigan State UniversityPeru
Bioavailable Iron in Locally Grown and “High Iron” Beans in Uganda: Assessment and Farmer Preferences – Pilot studyPilot Ohio State University,  National Agriculture Research Organization (NARO)Uganda
Pilot study to measure and enhance climate adaptation among livestock and potato farmers in ColombiaPilot Universidad de Los Andes,  CIATColombia
Pesticide Use when Farmers Grow Pest-Resistant Varieties: A Pilot Study in Viet NamPilot City St. George’s, University of London, Mekong Development Research Institute Viet Nam
The Impact of an export-oriented cash crop on farmer incomes and household outcomes: Cassava in Viet NamFull StudyCity St. George’s, University of LondonViet Nam
Seeds of Change: Adapting to Climate Change – Study on price incentives and DNA verification technology to encourage multiplication of quality seeds of groundnuts varieties. Full StudyUniversity of Chicago, Tufts University, ICRISATIndia (Odisha)

 

 

Recently Completed Studies

StudyCountryCategoryPartnersInnovation/Research/ContributionResearch OutputRelated publicationsCompletion Date
Sustained Adoption of Environmentally Sustainable Practices: Spillovers and Long-Run Impacts in Niger NigerAccountabilityTufts, UCSB, ICRISATDemi-Lune Rainwater Harvesting TechniqueAker, J. C., & Jack, B. K. (2023). Harvesting the rain: The adoption of environmental technologies in the Sahel. Review of Economics and Statistics, 1-52.How can Small-scale Farmers in Niger be
 Encouraged to Adopt Rainwater Harvesting?
 Results from a Pilot Study 
2022
Long-Term Diffusion and Impacts of Index-Based Livestock Insurance (KENYA)KenyaAccountabilityILRIILRI research on pastoralist risk management that led to the development of index-based livestock insuranceBarrett, C. B., Jensen, N., Morsink, K., Noritomo, Y., Son, H. H., Banerjee, R., & Teufel, N. (2024). Long-run Effects of Catastrophic Drought Insurance. October 2024. SPIA Briefing Note: Climate Change Mitigation and Adaptation2023
Evaluating the Restoration of the Commons: A Quasi-Experimental Impact Assessment of a Large-Scale Land Restoration Initiative in India Founded on the Tenets of Collective Action and Property Rights (INDIA)IndiaAccountabilityICRAF, IFPRI, Foundation for Ecological Security (FES)Promise of Commons Institutional innovation-NRM: IFPRI research on the importance of property rights and collective action for managing natural resourceHughes, K., Sharma, H., Priyadarshini, P. et al. Integrating Earth observation, biophysical, and survey data to evaluate the ecological impacts of a common land protection and restoration intervention in Rajasthan, India. Humanit Soc Sci Commun 11, 1535 (2024). 2024
Impact of a Second-Generation Conservation Agriculture Technology (Happy Seeder) on Crop Residue Burning and Air Quality in Northwestern Indo-Gangetic Plains (INDIA)IndiaAccountabilityCIMMYT, IISER (India), U MichiganHappy Seeder technology MachineryKrishna, V. V., Deshpande, M., Pillai, D., Cariappa, A., Kubitza, C., Jat, M. L., & Jain, M. (2024). Beyond Fields: Conservation Agriculture as a Public Good in Reducing Air Pollution. SPIA Fest - Presentation at the SPIA Fest pre-conference to the International Conference of Agricultural Economists (ICAE), 2 August 2024.SPIA Briefing Note: Environmental Externalities of Agricultural Intensification2023
Land-Use Land-Cover Change (LULCC) Impacts of Sorghum and Millet Upscaling Project in Mali (MALI)MaliAccountabilityIAMO (Germany), UC Louvain, UCSB, ICRISATImproved variety-crop: Improved sorghum and millet varietiesAbeygunawardane, D., Traore, S., Traore, S., Kerubo, V., Ngungu, S., Reiner, F., Brandt, M., Fensholt, R., & Kumar, P. (2024). LULCC Impacts of Agricultural Intensification in Mali, Borlaug or Jevons. Presentation at the SPIA Fest pre-conference to the International Conference of Agricultural Economists (ICAE), 2 August 2024.SPIA Briefing Note: Environmental Externalities of Agricultural Intensification2024
Evaluating the Impact of Stress-Tolerant Rice Varieties Through Remote Sensing and Econometric Methods (BANGLADESH)BangladeshAccountabilityIRRI, University of ArizonaImproved variety – Stress-Tolerant Rice Varieties: Submergence tolerant riceMichler, J. D., Rafi, D. A. A., Giezendanner, J., Josephson, A., Pede, V. O., & Tellman, E. (2024). Impact Evaluations in Data Poor Settings: The Case of Stress-Tolerant Rice Varieties in Bangladesh.SPIA Briefing Note: Climate Change Mitigation and Adaptation2024
Rangeland Health and Index-Based Livestock Insurance: Innovations in Measurement and Evaluation (KENYA, ETHIOPIA)Kenya, EthiopiaAccountabiliyCornell, ILRIIndex-Based Livestock Insurance (IBLI)Wilcox, S. W., Barrett, C. B., Jensen, N. D., Clark, P., Fava, F., Kahiu, N., Soto, G. E., & Sun, Y. (2024). The Environmental Impacts of Microfinance: Index-Based Livestock Insurance and East African Rangelands. Presentation at the SPIA Fest pre-conference to the International Conference of Agricultural Economists (ICAE), 2 August 2024.SPIA Briefing Note: Environmental Externalities of Agricultural Intensification2022
SPIA Briefing Note: Climate Change Mitigation and Adaptation
Communal Grazing Exclosures for Scaling Improved Forages in the Ethiopian HighlandsEthiopiaLearningUniversidad de los Andes, ILRIScaling approaches for improved foragesNo formal output was generated — it served mainly as an information-gathering phase.Conversion of Communal Grazing Lands into Exclosures Restored Soil Properties in the Semi-Arid Lowlands of Northern Ethiopia2022
Application of scaling frameworks to grazing exclosures in Ethiopia
Diffusion and Adoption of Labor-Saving Technology in the Presence of Complementarity With Other Inputs, Intra-household Frictions, and Coordination Costs, Uganda (Pilot)UgandaLearningIPA, AfricaRice, Northwestern U, UC Berkeley, U Sydney.Two-row Adapted Motorized Paddy Weeder (AMW) developed in TZ as part of SARD-DCNo formal output was generated — it served mainly as an information-gathering phase.Two-row adapted Motorized Weeder (AMW) for irrigated and rainfed lowland systems in sub-Saharan Africa2023
Scaling Pathways for Accelerating Adoption of the Sweetpotato Triple S Technology in Dry Areas of MozambiqueMozambiqueLearningWilliam and Mary, CIPTriple S (Storage in Sand and Sprouting) technologyNo formal output was generated — it served mainly as an information-gathering phase. 2022
Demand and Liquidity Coordination to Foster the Adoption for Livestock Vaccinations: An Experiment with Small-Holder Dairy Cooperatives in KenyaKenyaLearningILRI, UC Santa Cruz, Indian School of BusinessVaccine Infection and Treatment Method - ECF-ITM, developed 40 years ago and regularly improved but still not widely adopted.Teufel, N., Githinji, J., Rao, J., Xu, G., Maina, K., Aggarwal, S., Robinson, J., & Spearot, A., (2024) Demand and Liquidity Coordination to Foster the Adoption for Livestock Vaccinations: An Experiment with Small‐Holder Dairy Cooperatives in KenyaSPIA Briefing Note: Targeting of Agricultural Technologies2024
Diffusion of Machine-Harvestable Chickpeas and Implications for Labor Markets in IndiaIndiaLearningUC Berkeley, J-PAL, ICRISATMachine-harvestable Chickpeas (MHCP): Erect to semi-erect growth habit and the first pod height is at least 25 cm above the soil surface*Neduraman, S., Mahajan, A., & Mitra, S. (2024). Diffusion of Machine Harvestable Chickpea and its Impacts on Mechanization and Labor Market in India. Presentation at the SPIA Fest pre-conference to the International Conference of Agricultural Economists (ICAE), 2 August 2024.SPIA Briefing Note: CGIAR Research on Mechanization2023
Small Mechanization Impact Stimuli in Ethiopia (SMISE)EthiopiaLearningWilliams College, Amherst College, CIMMYTSmall mechanization hire service business models*Godlonton, S., Gebresilasse, M., & Jaleta, M. (2024). Small Scale Farm Mechanization: Evidence from Ethiopia. Presentation at the SPIA Fest pre-conference to the International Conference of Agricultural Economists (ICAE), 2 August 2024.SPIA Briefing Note: Targeting of Agricultural Technologies2024
SPIA Briefing Note: CGIAR Research on Mechanization
SPIA FEST 2024: Roundup of the Evidence from the 2019-2024 SPIA Workplan
SPIA Fest 2024: Assessing the impacts of international agricultural research: New methods, rigorous evidence, better decisions
Picture Based Advisories (PBA) – Tailored digital extension based on individual field pictures LearningIFPRI, Wageningen UniversityPicture Based Advisories (PBA) appNo formal output was generated — it served mainly as an information-gathering phase.IFPRI Discussion Paper 02322 December 2024 Impacts of Personalized Picture-based Crop Advisories Experimental Evidence from India and Kenya2024
Technology Adoption and Market-Access: On-Farm Agribusinesses in RwandaRwandaLearningWorld Bank, CIAIVR-based marketplace for smallholder farmersNo formal output was generated — it served mainly as an information-gathering phase.Technology adoption and market access: On-farm agribusinesses in Rwanda2024
Institutionalizing, Tracking and Monitoring the Dissemination of Aflasafe in AfricaAfricaMethodsIITAAflasafeNo formal output was generated — it served mainly as an information-gathering phase.Scaling Aflasafe: From lab-based innovation to large-scale aflatoxin mitigation across Africa2022
Data Collection on the GIFT Dissemination Process From Hatcheries to Farmers in BangladeshBangladeshMethodsWorldFishGenetically Improved Farmed Tilapia (GIFT)No formal output was generated — it served mainly as an information-gathering phase. 2021
Data Collection on the Historical Dissemination of ASI Threshers in Senegal and NigeriaNigeriaMethodsAfricaRiceASI ThreshersNo formal output was generated — it served mainly as an information-gathering phase. 2021
Data Collection on the Historical Dissemination of Early-Maturing Lentil Varieties in Bangladesh and IndiaBangladesh, IndiaMethodsICARDAEarly-Maturing Lentil VarietiesNo formal output was generated — it served mainly as an information-gathering phase. 2024
Impacts of Blast Resistant Wheat in BangladeshBangladeshMethodsCIMMYTCompare BARI Gom 33 variety to the entire crop portfolio – not just a farmer’s other wheat varieties. Two-stage experiment to demonstrate a methodology for determining whether some farmers successfully adapt to abrupt environmental change by switching their crop portfolioNo formal output was generated — it served mainly as an information-gathering phase. 2024